Protecting Carriers from Bad Brokers

by TQL 9/3/2010

By many accounts, it appears that the economy is bouncing back. This is good news for the trucking industry. As consumer spending rises, so does the need for trucks to transport the goods needed to replenish inventories. At the same time, this need opens the door for new companies to enter the freight brokerage industry.

Historically, the freight brokerage industry has been one of the top new business ventures because of its low start-up and operating costs. In theory, anyone with experience in the industry and access to a computer can connect shippers with carriers looking for a load. Not everyone has the same motives for starting their business, however. 

When a carrier accepts a load from a broker, it’s with the understanding that the broker will pay them upon receipt of the carriers’ bills of lading. There are some brokers, however, who collect payment from the shipper and never pay the carrier. In other instances, the broker is not paid by the shipper at all and ends up filing for bankruptcy. The broker willingly pays the low fees associated with filing for bankruptcy or takes the hit of losing its surety bond instead of fulfilling its financial obligations. In the end, the carrier loses out.

Currently, there are very few requirements or government regulations that exist in the freight brokerage industry. The carrier has few opportunities to pursue any legal action as a way to recover its losses. However, in mid-June, two senators from Main and Minnesota introduced “The Motor Carrier Protection Act” to address this issue.

The bill is designed to protect small trucking companies and owner-operators from fraudulent freight brokers by adding new regulations to the industry. As outlined in a recent article by Transport Topics, if passed, the bill would:

  • Increase the broker surety bond to $100,000 from $10,000 and apply the requirements to freight forwarders.
  • Establish stricter requirements for companies seeking broker or forwarder authority and stiffer penalties for those who violate the regulations.
  • Require that brokers or forwarders renew their authority annually.
  • Clarify that carriers who arrange freight for another carrier for compensation must have the appropriate broker authority and surety bond, in addition to their motor carrier operating authority.

Total Quality Logistics wants our carrier network to know, in general, we support any action that makes it more difficult for criminals to cause harm in our industry. We too have been the victim of many scams in the past and understand how carriers feel. We value the drivers we work with and pledge to continue using the lessons we’ve learned to protect you in the future.

More importantly, we want to reassure our carrier network of TQL’s financial stability and commitment. We already have a $100,000 surety bond. We do not automatically change our payment terms in the event we are not paid by the shipper. And, we have earned the highest credit ratings possible from Dun & Bradstreet, Blue Book, Red Book and the Transportation Intermediaries Association.

Finally, because we realize that you don’t work with TQL on every load you or your drivers haul, we want to remind you of a few important ways you can protect yourself and your company when working with other brokers.


Comments

9/21/2010 10:26:47 AM #

We agree wholeheartedly with this new proposed legislation.  We have been 'burned' many times ourselves, and owning a Brokerage company ourselves we certainly agree that Bond requirements need to be much higher.  Every single time we have been 'burned' the Bonding company always gives us the same answer.  They have many, many thousand of dollars worth of claims against a $10,000 bond and we collect nothing.  We feel that bonding companies should require much higher limits and not be allowed to issue $10K bonds.  On several of our claims it has been the same bonding company issueing the bonds to these fraudulent brokers.

Desert Jewell Logistics, Ken Lowry, Pres United States

9/21/2010 11:53:16 AM #

I am all for the new rules, the problem will be educating the shippers to only use brokers with the proper authorities.  Often times, brokers without the proper authorities offer great prices to shippers and undercut everyone, knowing fully that they will not be paying the carrier.

The laws should also be amended to give police the tools to put away the criminals who undermine the current laws.  Better enforcement is also necessary if this is to be a success.

I would also support changes that to renew the license, the broker should carry a bond equal to some calculation based on their Accounts Receivable and their Owners Equity as of their last fiscal year.    This would assist the smaller brokerages and reward those brokerages who pay in a timely manner.

Jim Langeveld (Country Transport) Canada

9/26/2010 8:11:17 AM #

This may be important to a broker company to keep competition at bay making it impossible for the average
Person to start a brokerage company .  But what would
If your realy interested in helping drivers . How about trying to
Get a law passed that's mandatory drivers get detention
Pay after two hours . Instead of setting at cvs for six hours
And getting nothing or Miller beer and getting your load canceled . And only get 135.00 .Or better yet show the
The shippers rate and brokers percentage .Then we might
Be able to save a little money to cover the expense of a non
Paying broker. I probably just waisted another 15 min of my
Life writing this and would be shocked to be heard and get a
Response   Thankyou just a driver

Ron Hippensteel United States

9/29/2010 6:42:33 AM #

The $10,000 dollar bond should never have been allowed, these brokers file bankrupcy, then get a new bond, over and over. Just using a new name, burning people "GOOD PEOPLE" , the trucking company doesn't just not get paid they are also out the driver pay, and they cost of the fuel. The guy doing the "WRONG" doesn't loose anything! We pay to do credit checks, which the brokers with bad credit should not even be aloud to post loads on any load board. The trucking industry has really went to hell from all this being allowed.

Samantha Bruggeman United States

Add comment


(Will show your Gravatar icon)

  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading




About Us

About TQL

Welcome to Total Quality Logistics' Carrier Connection website. Once each quarter, we will update this website with news and information that we hope will help our drivers and dispatchers stay connected with our company and the truckload industry. [More]


View our 2011 Calendar
Forward to a friend

TQL Contact Info

Call 800-580-3101 / 513-831-2600
Fax 513-695-7630
Write PO Box 799 Cincinnati, OH 45150